- Received from
- Tourist on Desert Island
- Recorded trade choices
- Needlefish or Seahorse
- Encounter
- Pufferfish
- Next hand-in
- Pufferfish fin
Game version and evidence: Base equipment prices, damage and catch pools: Patch 1.0.10 reference. These figures are not a new playtest of the latest release.
Game imagery: How to Fish by Dazed Games. Rights remain with the respective owners. Media and source notes.
Keep a fish for the Tourist
The Tourist under the tree exchanges an eligible endangered creature for the Carrot. Needlefish and Seahorse are the recorded choices in this route. Both appear in the Standard Lure pool, so speak to the Tourist before deciding what to sell from a fishing trip.
Reserve the trade candidate as soon as it is caught. One designated quest object is easier to track than a pile of bodies that the crew is treating as general sale stock.
Prepare the Carrot encounter
The Carrot starts Pufferfish, the Desert story boss. Use it with the Fishing Rod only after weapons and recovery supplies are ready. A Standard Boss Lure serves Blue Shark instead, so check the bait when working on the island unlock.
Give yourself room for broad sideways movement and use the terrain deliberately. Chasing directly after the boss through its charge cycle makes it harder to preserve the space needed for the next dodge.
Protect the fin after the fight
Collect Pufferfish’s fin and complete the story hand-in to reveal Rocks Island. The Carrot solves the encounter trigger; the fin solves the island unlock. Finishing the fight without returning the required item leaves the route incomplete.
Blue Shark and the Grillmaster are a separate Desert objective that unlocks cooking. It is useful preparation for future fights, but it should not be confused with the Tourist–Carrot–Pufferfish chain.
Finish the creature exchange instead of buying another lure
The Carrot is a reward from the Tourist, not the ordinary Desert supply sold as Standard Lure. Begin by reading the Tourist request and retaining an accepted endangered creature. Needlefish and Seahorse are the two choices recorded in this route. Neither a higher-value fish nor a visually unusual variant should be substituted without checking what the current request actually accepts.
Both recorded candidates occur in the regular Standard pairing, which costs 15 coins per purchase in the historical table. That gives the ordinary fishing trip a concrete story purpose: obtain and protect an acceptable delivery. Once you have one, return to the Tourist before converting the entire haul to cash. More lure purchases do not advance a delivery that is already sitting in the stock pile.
Understand the value you are choosing not to sell
Needlefish has a recorded 60-coin base and Seahorse 100. If either is accepted by your active request, choosing a Needlefish rather than a Seahorse means keeping a body with a 40-coin smaller unmodified reference for the exchange. That is an opportunity-cost comparison, not a claim that Needlefish is easier to find or that the Tourist pays a coin difference.
Do not delay the route indefinitely just to optimize that comparison. When the only suitable candidate you have is a Seahorse, trading it can be more useful than spending additional time and supplies seeking a cheaper-bodied option. The value of reaching Pufferfish and opening Rocks is not represented by the raw sale column, and the table contains no encounter frequencies with which to price the wait.
Use the reward when the fight plan is ready
After the trade, set the Carrot aside while preparing the Fishing Rod and combat setup. The object solves the trigger requirement; it does not supply food, ammunition or room to dodge. Read the Pufferfish encounter guide and choose an area that allows broad movement before using the bait. Keep a clear route away from a charge rather than relying on continuous damage from one cramped position.
The nearby Standard Boss Lure is intended for Blue Shark, while the Coconut is associated with Bing Bong. Both can consume money needed for story preparation without producing the same encounter. Inspect the actual attachment before the cast, particularly if several players have been buying and sorting different Desert supplies during the same session.
Change the reserved item after the boss
When Pufferfish is defeated, the progression object changes from Carrot to fin. Retrieve that distinctive quest result and return it to finish the Tourist route. The historical whole-creature base is not a price assigned to the detached fin, and neither figure should overrule the hand-in. Keep the item until the conversation is complete and the Rocks route is available.
This transition is an easy place for co-op responsibilities to become unclear. The player managing bait may think the fight is the last step, while the person clearing the area may treat everything left behind as ordinary sale stock. Name a fin carrier before combat, then put the delivery ahead of the next shopping round.
Separate an unfinished Tourist route from an unfinished grill
If no Carrot has been received, check the Tourist candidate and the completed trade. If Pufferfish does not start, check the Fishing Rod and quest-bait attachment. If the boss is defeated but Rocks is still locked, inspect the fin delivery. Each observation points to a different missing link, so repeating a Blue Shark attempt is unlikely to repair the actual problem.
Grillmaster asks for Blue Shark and opens cooking, a useful side service. That service can support later preparation but is not the route marker produced by the Pufferfish fin. Complete the desired task, confirm its own result and only then decide whether the remaining Desert supplies should go towards cooking access, optional collection or departure.
Guide images
View 7 related images







